Myers-Briggs and the Need for Discipleship

March 15, 2013

I am an ENTJ. If you don’t know what it is, don’t worry. I didn’t know until a week ago either, when my organization had us go through a test and see what type of personality we have. I was happy with what I found, and it was a tad creepy to read a characterization from a book about my personality type and have that feeling that someone has been watching me my entire life.

I love being an ENTJ and doing ENTJ like things. I feel this description matches me: “[ENTJs] tend to be self-driven, motivating, energetic, assertive, confident, and competitive. They generally take a big-picture view and build a long-term strategy. They typically know what they want and may mobilize others to help them attain their goals. ENTJs are often sought out as leaders due to an innate ability to direct groups of people. Unusually influential and organized, they may sometimes judge others by their own tough standards, failing to take personal needs into account” (from Gifts Differing: Understanding Personality Type).

Another portrait: “Inefficiency is especially rejected by ENTJs, and repetition of error causes them to become impatient. For the ENTJ, there must always be a reason for doing anything, and people’s feelings usually are not sufficient reason” (from Please Understand Me).

At this point, after reading over these portraits again, I feel like I am known. There is an understanding about who I am and how I operate. My next inclination is that this somehow justifies how I have acted or worked for years and years. It’s just who I am.

There is a weird juxtaposition in our Christian faith that has the doctrine of sin on one side—we are all born in darkness and sin—and a comfort in God’s image on the other—we are known by God and each of us is his handiwork. One is our starting place, a horrible place, and the other is our comforting, victorious place where we finally feel known and accepted by God. We can all say God made me this way.

There is something categorically wrong with saying God made me this way. We should be saying God is making me this way. The present view, the one we see flushed out in so many spiritual gifts tests or disciple-making relationships, is a static view. It identifies your strengths, your personality and then spins an optimistic view of “this is how God made you.” I would be happy to just know I am this way always and forever, but that is neglecting the role of sanctification and discipleship in the Christian life. I am an ENTJ and always will be, but there are some parts of being an ENTJ that are not how God wants me to be. We cannot take for granted that the way we are inclined to operate—in my case, being judgmental, keeping a record of wrongs, being indifferent to feelings—might not be the way that God wants us to operate.

It is wonderful to take stock of our strengths, our personality and our character. But if we do so without reflection and just blindly accept who we are right now, we are refusing to enter into the tough, hard slog of sanctification and discipleship. I am an ENTJ, and I love it. But I am also in desperate need for discipleship to learn to curb my less than gracious ENTJ tendencies. What about you? What kind of personality do you have and what are characteristics of your personality in need of discipleship?

Thomas

Thomas

Posts Twitter Facebook

Thomas Turner has been blogging on Everyday Liturgy for the past six years. He enjoys reading, writing, cooking and gardening.

3 responses to Myers-Briggs and the Need for Discipleship

  1. Greetings from a fellow ENTJ! Great post. I took the MB test when I was in undergrad studying Elementary Education. The professor divided the room into quadrants and asked us to get into groups based on four major personality types. Half the room when to one group and the other have went to a different group. I sat by myself in my own quadrant. My traits didn’t exactly fit the elementary teacher image. Then, I got to seminary and discovered that not all churches are friendly towards females in ministry. As a female who is “assertive, confident, and competitive,” I struggled with the question of why God would make me this way. During this time, I took the StrengthFinders test and was shocked at the results. It fit me perfectly, but it was all of the traits that I did not like about myself. A wise mentor explained that our strengths become our weaknesses when we live them out in a way that doesn’t glorify God. For example, confidence is helpful because my worth is not tied to the approval of others. However, it becomes a weakness when it turns into pride. Sanctification involves learning how to be me in a way that honors God. It’s like that quote about using my powers for good and not evil. Instead of being ashamed of the traits, I can embrace them and seek to use them to glorify God.

  2. This was a cool post!

    I’m an ENFP
    (I’m almost split T and F). I JUST took the test again for my Master of Arts and Christina Leadership class.

    I’ve noticed that since I first took this MB temperaments test about 12 years ago I’m changed…not at the core level….but I’ve been refined. It’s like you say…what I am becoming.

    For instance, I’m more Feeling than Thinking, and less extroverted. I was 30 of 30 Intuitive…(this tends to scare people) but I’ve developed a contemplative side to me where I’m more in the here and now. . . .”Zen” (?), if we keep the baggage off that word. I’ve become more ordered and organized and lessened my P too, becoming less anxious when I have reduced options.

    So, for me, it’s true what they say the first half of one’s life we come into our own and the second half we develop we our “shadow side”. So, youngster, that’s your “heads up” ! :)

    Another test I just did that I highly recommend comes with the book “Strength Finders 2.0″ (the people at Gallup) –Very helpful for organizations too and team building. http://strengths.gallup.com/default.aspx

Leave a Reply